MarTech Verdict

Reviews · HR & payroll

Best Payroll Services for Staffing Companies in 2026: 7 Compared

Seven payroll options for staffing companies compared on pay/bill, ACA tracking for temps, funding and published prices, checked 17 October 2026.

By the MarTech Verdict Editorial Team · Published October 17, 2026

Quick picks

1

TempWorks

Best for agencies that want payroll, tax filing and invoice funding from one staffing vendor

Pricing not published (quote)
checked 17 Oct 2026
2

Avionté

Best for agencies replacing separate recruiting, payroll and billing tools with one platform

Pricing not published (quote)
checked 17 Oct 2026
3

Bullhorn (Middle Office + payroll partner)

Best for agencies already recruiting in Bullhorn

Front office from $99/user/mo (Starter) · Middle Office quote
checked 17 Oct 2026
4

Gusto

Best for start-up agencies with a few placements and no back-office budget yet

Simple $49/mo + $6/person · Plus $80/mo + $12/person
checked 17 Oct 2026
5

PrismHR (via a PEO or payroll bureau)

Best for agencies that want to outsource payroll to a bureau running staffing-ready software

Pricing not published (quote via the bureau)
checked 17 Oct 2026
6

ADP

Best for agencies that want a large general payroll provider and the Wisely pay card

Pricing not published (quote)
checked 17 Oct 2026
7

Asure

Best for small agencies that want earned wage access on a general payroll plan

Pricing not published (quote)
checked 17 Oct 2026
How we put this together: We read each provider's official pricing, product and help pages on 17 October 2026 and compared pay/bill from a single timesheet, ACA measurement tracking, workers' comp code handling, onboarding and E-Verify, pay cards and payroll funding, and published prices. Rules come from the DOL, IRS (26 CFR 54.4980H-3) and USCIS. We couldn't confirm Paychex's staffing features or prices, so it isn't ranked. We haven't bought or run these services for this article. Prices are in USD as shown on that date.

Searches for staffing payroll usually come from one of two places: a new agency that has just signed its first client and needs to pay temps on Friday, or an established agency whose payroll, invoicing and ACA spreadsheets no longer agree with each other. The tool you need depends on which one you are.

The deciding feature is pay/bill. A staffing agency is normally the W-2 employer of its temps and also the vendor that bills the client for their hours. When both come from the same approved timesheet, with a pay rate, bill rate and workers’ comp code on each line, payroll and invoices can’t drift apart. General payroll software only does the first half.

The second is the Affordable Care Act. Once an agency averages 50 full-time employees including equivalents, it’s an applicable large employer, and temps count. The IRS look-back rules (26 CFR 54.4980H-3) include an example of a temporary staffing firm treating new temps as variable-hour employees, measured over 3 to 12 months. Software that tracks those periods per worker is close to mandatory at that size.

The tools

1. TempWorks: staffing payroll with tax and funding in-house

TempWorks sells recruiting, CRM, payroll, tax management, time management and ACA administration as one suite. Its time module says timecards are “submitted for payroll processing and client invoicing,” with mobile punches using geofencing or facial recognition. The ACA module tracks measurement periods and warns you when workers approach full-time eligibility. Its tax engine picks taxes by zip code with multi-state reciprocity, and it offers full-service tax filing. Funding comes from its sister company, Lone Oak Payroll. Pricing isn’t published.

Who it isn’t for: a two-person agency that just wants to pay five temps. It’s a full back office and is sold through a demo.

2. Avionté: one platform from candidate to invoice

Avionté combines ATS, CRM, payroll and billing. It says it creates “client-specific invoices based on approved time, rates, and custom billing rules,” and it lists I-9 verification, E-Verify integration, ACA tracking, WOTC and multi-jurisdiction tax reporting. Temps can be paid same day through the CHANGE pay card, powered by rapid!. Its SmartFund feature handles invoice funding inside the back office. Avionté doesn’t publish prices, and its service terms say ACA reporting is a separately priced annual add-on.

Who it isn’t for: agencies happy with their current ATS that only want better payroll; Avionté is built to replace the whole stack.

3. Bullhorn: pay and bill for agencies that already recruit in Bullhorn

Bullhorn is the only vendor here with published prices, but they’re for the recruiting front office: Starter $99 and Core $165 per user per month, with Pro and Max quoted. Its Middle Office, a separately quoted product, verifies timesheets, applies pay and bill rules and automates client invoices. Bullhorn says over 1 million workers are paid monthly through it. The payroll run itself goes through a partner; its US pay and bill page names Greenshades.

Who it isn’t for: agencies not on Bullhorn’s ATS. You’d be adopting three pieces (front office, middle office, payroll partner) at once.

4. Gusto: the cheapest way to start paying temps

For a brand-new agency, published general payroll can be enough for the first placements. Gusto Simple is $49 a month plus $6 per person in one state, and Plus is $80 plus $12 per person for multi-state payroll and time tracking. Runs are unlimited, so weekly pay costs nothing extra. E-Verify is $5 per submission and remote I-9 is $20 per submission. At 40 people on Plus, that’s $560 a month by our arithmetic.

Who it isn’t for: anyone billing clients at a markup from timesheets. Gusto has no bill rates, invoicing or ACA look-back tracking.

5. PrismHR: staffing payroll through a bureau or PEO

PrismHR is software for PEOs and payroll bureaus, so you’d use it through one of them. It describes itself as specializing in complex payroll for staffing firms on its Bullhorn adapter page, which sends time from Bullhorn and returns labor costs. Help docs describe billing one fee per workers’ comp class covering FUTA, SUTA, FICA and comp, and its ACA module tracks variable-hour employees over 6 to 12 months. E-Verify cases open once an I-9 is approved.

Who it isn’t for: agencies that want to run payroll in-house on their own license.

6. ADP: general payroll with a pay card

ADP’s RUN and Workforce Now packages are quote-only. ADP has no staffing industry page, and we couldn’t confirm pay/bill, comp-code billing or ACA look-back features for staffing on its site. What it does document is the Wisely pay card, whose page carries testimonials from staffing companies; TempWorks lists Wisely as a partner too.

Who it isn’t for: agencies wanting one system for payroll and client billing.

7. Asure: general payroll with earned wage access

Asure’s three plans (Payroll; Payroll & HR; Payroll, HR, & Time) are quote-only, and each lists earned wage access and electronic employment verification. AsureWorks is a managed service in which Asure runs payroll while you stay the employer. It has no staffing-specific page.

Who it isn’t for: agencies that need pay/bill or comp-code billing.

Quick comparison

ToolPay/bill from one timesheetACA tracking for tempsFunding optionPublished price
TempWorksYesYes (measurement periods)Lone Oak Payroll (sister company)No
AviontéYesYes (reporting add-on)SmartFund, Scale FundingNo
BullhornYes, via Middle OfficeCouldn’t confirm on current pagesCouldn’t confirmFront office only
GustoNoNoNoYes
PrismHRVia Bullhorn or other front officeYes (6 to 12 months)Couldn’t confirmNo
ADPCouldn’t confirmCouldn’t confirmCouldn’t confirmNo
AsureNoCouldn’t confirmCouldn’t confirmNo

How to choose

  1. Start from your recruiting system. If you’re on Bullhorn, price Middle Office plus its payroll partner, or a PrismHR bureau, before switching platforms. If you’re not, compare TempWorks and Avionté as full replacements.
  2. Test the overtime case. Ask the vendor to show a temp who works for two clients in one week. Overtime is owed on total hours over 40 in the workweek (DOL Fact Sheet #23), and the system should catch it.
  3. Price weekly runs. At 52 payrolls a year, any per-run charge adds up. Use our payroll cost calculator for the employer tax side.
  4. Get onboarding right for short jobs. I-9 Section 2 is due within three business days, or on day one for jobs shorter than that (USCIS). Mobile onboarding matters when temps start the day they’re placed.
  5. Read funding and pay-card terms before you need them. Ask for the advance rate, fees and reserve, and what workers pay for same-day pay. If you’d rather outsource HR entirely, compare a PEO, and see our home care payroll software list if you also place caregivers.

FAQ

What's the difference between staffing payroll software and regular payroll software?
Staffing software ties each approved timesheet to two rates: the pay rate for the temp and the bill rate for the client, plus a workers' comp code. One approval produces the paycheck and the invoice. Regular payroll software such as Gusto or ADP RUN pays people and files taxes but doesn't invoice clients, so an agency using it needs a separate billing process.
How much does payroll software for a staffing agency cost?
The staffing platforms we read on 17 October 2026 (TempWorks, Avionté, Bullhorn Middle Office, PrismHR) don't publish prices. General payroll is published: Gusto Plus at $80 a month plus $12 per person works out to $560 a month for 40 people, before any invoicing tool. Bullhorn's recruiting front office starts at $99 per user per month, with pay and bill quoted separately.
Do temps count toward the ACA's 50-employee threshold?
Yes, if your agency is their employer, which is the usual setup. The IRS counts full-time employees and full-time equivalents averaged over the prior year. Above 50, you need to offer coverage to full-time employees, and the look-back measurement method in 26 CFR 54.4980H-3 lets you measure new variable-hour temps for 3 to 12 months before deciding whether they're full-time.
Can a staffing agency get help covering weekly payroll?
Some staffing vendors offer it. TempWorks says its sister company, Lone Oak Payroll, advances a share of invoice value and collects from your clients. Avionté describes SmartFund, which lets you pick invoices for funding inside its back office, and lists Scale Funding as a partner. Neither publishes rates.