MarTech Verdict

Reviews · HR & payroll

Best Home Care Payroll Services in 2026: 6 Options Ranked

Six home care payroll options compared on built-in payroll, EVV links, overtime and per-visit pay support and published prices, checked 17 October 2026.

By the MarTech Verdict Editorial Team · Published October 17, 2026

Quick picks

1

HHAeXchange CarePay

Best for Medicaid agencies that want payroll paid from the same verified visits they bill

Pricing not published (quote)
checked 17 Oct 2026
2

Viventium

Best for agencies that want a healthcare-only payroll provider next to their care software

Pricing not published (quote)
checked 17 Oct 2026
3

AlayaCare

Best for multi-branch or multi-state agencies replacing several systems at once

Pricing not published (custom quote plus implementation fees)
checked 17 Oct 2026
4

CareSmartz360

Best for agencies that want to keep ADP or Paychex and feed it from care software

Pricing not published (quote by active clients)
checked 17 Oct 2026
5

AxisCare

Best for private-pay and mixed agencies choosing their own payroll partner

Pricing not published (quote by client count)
checked 17 Oct 2026
6

Poppins Payroll

Best for families paying a parent's caregiver directly

$49/mo for 1 employee + $10/mo per additional employee
checked 17 Oct 2026
How we put this together: We read each provider's official pricing, product, payroll and integration pages on 17 October 2026 and compared whether payroll is built in or exported, which EVV systems and payroll providers each names, how each describes overtime, per-visit and live-in pay, and published prices. Rules come from the DOL (29 CFR 552.109, Fact Sheet 79D, Field Assistance Bulletin 2025-4), CMS and IRS Publication 926. We couldn't read Paychex's or Care.com HomePay's sites, so neither is ranked. We haven't bought or run these services for this article. Prices are in USD as shown on that date.

Home care payroll looks simple until you add up a real caregiver’s week: four visits a day, three clients, a drive between each, maybe an overnight on Saturday. Those hours live in your scheduling and EVV system, not in your payroll software. The question that decides your setup is whether payroll reads those hours directly or someone exports and fixes them every week.

The rules make that matter. DOL counts travel between clients during the workday as hours worked that the agency pays (Fact Sheet 79D). If a caregiver has 20 minutes between each of four daily visits, that’s an hour of paid travel a day, or five hours in a five-day week, and it can push a week past 40. Overtime for agencies is in flux at the federal level: the regulation barring agencies from the companionship and live-in exemptions (29 CFR 552.109) is still on the books, but the DOL stopped enforcing it in July 2025 (FAB 2025-4) while it works on a rescission. Whichever way that lands, you want software that can calculate overtime across clients.

The tools

1. HHAeXchange CarePay: payroll from verified visits

HHAeXchange is best known for EVV and Medicaid billing, and it lists itself as the state EVV aggregator in nine states, including Florida, Illinois, New Jersey and Pennsylvania. CarePay, which it calls “payroll built for homecare,” runs on the same data as scheduling, EVV and billing. HHAeXchange says blended overtime, shift differentials and wage parity calculate automatically and caregivers are paid only for verified, approved visits. Direct deposits take two business days, per its FAQ. ADP and WorkMarket are payroll partners; DailyPay and Keeper offer early pay. No prices are published.

Who it isn’t for: small private-pay agencies that don’t need Medicaid tooling. Its payroll page also doesn’t describe travel-time or 24-hour-shift handling.

2. Viventium: payroll that only serves healthcare

Viventium sells payroll and HR only to healthcare providers, from skilled nursing to home care. Its home care page lists pay setups for Medicaid waiver programs, wage parity, consumer-directed programs, joint employment and live-in caregivers, with retroactive and blended-rate overtime for staff on more than one pay rate. Its home health page supports pay by visit with overtime recalculated. AxisCare and Kantime appear in its partner directory, and AxisCare and CareSmartz360 list Viventium as a payroll integration. Pricing is quote only.

Who it isn’t for: agencies wanting one vendor for everything. Viventium doesn’t do scheduling or EVV.

3. AlayaCare: one platform for larger agencies

AlayaCare covers scheduling, EVV, billing and payroll. Its payroll module, it says, processes base pay and overtime from punch data and handles breaks, holidays, spread of hours and wage parity, with exports or direct integrations to outside payroll systems. EVV is built for state Medicaid programs with GPS, phone and offline clock-in. Pricing is a custom quote by size, regions and modules, plus one-time implementation fees, and there’s no free trial.

Who it isn’t for: small agencies that want to start next week. It names no payroll partners, so ask which ones are live integrations.

4. CareSmartz360: feed the payroll you already use

CareSmartz360 is agency software that hands hours to your payroll provider. It lists integrations with ADP, Paychex, Viventium and QuickBooks, and says Paychex Flex “takes gross wages from CareSmartz360.” It names Sandata, Netsmart, HHAeXchange, CareBridge, AuthentiCare and eMedNY as EVV connections and says its phone and GPS EVV apps carry no extra fee. Pricing is by active clients per month.

Who it isn’t for: anyone hoping the payroll provider will fix overtime. Because it exports gross wages, travel and overtime have to be right in CareSmartz360.

5. AxisCare: care software with a payroll marketplace

AxisCare doesn’t run payroll; its integration marketplace lists ADP, Paylocity, Viventium and QuickBooks, plus Tapcheck and ZayZoon for early wage access. EVV works with HHAeXchange, Sandata, AuthentiCare, CareBridge and Netsmart. AxisCare says billing, scheduling, the caregiver and admin apps, EVV and reporting are in its base price, quoted by client count starting at 25 clients.

Who it isn’t for: agencies that need paid travel time calculated for them. AxisCare documents mileage and expense reports, so travel pay depends on your payroll partner.

6. Poppins Payroll: for families, not agencies

If your family hires a caregiver directly, you’re a household employer. Poppins Payroll is $49 a month for one employee and $10 for each additional one, with tax registration, quarterly filings and year-end W-2, W-3 and Schedule H included. Its senior care page covers live-in and overnight caregivers and says the parent receiving care is the employer on the account. Filing for a partial year costs $49 per quarter or $110 for year-end if you leave early.

Who it isn’t for: agencies. It’s built for one household paying its own workers.

Quick comparison

OptionPayrollEVVPayroll partners namedPublished price
HHAeXchange CarePayBuilt inYes, state aggregator in 9 statesADP, WorkMarketNo
ViventiumIs the payroll providerNon/a (works with AxisCare, Kantime)No
AlayaCareBuilt in, plus exportsYesNone namedNo
CareSmartz360Export of gross wagesYes, includedADP, Paychex, Viventium, QuickBooksNo
AxisCareThrough partnersYes, included in baseADP, Paylocity, Viventium, QuickBooksNo
Poppins PayrollHousehold payrollNon/a$49/mo + $10 per extra employee

How to choose

  1. Follow the hours. Pick the payroll that reads the same verified visits you bill. Re-keying hours is where travel time and overtime get lost.
  2. Ask for a three-client test week. Have each vendor show one caregiver with visits at three clients, travel between them and more than 40 total hours, and check the overtime it produces.
  3. Check per-visit and overnight setups. A flat visit rate still needs a weekly minimum wage and overtime check (29 CFR 778.112), and sleep time on 24-hour shifts can only be excluded by agreement, up to 8 hours (29 CFR 785.22).
  4. Match your state’s EVV setup. Confirm the vendor sends data the way your Medicaid program requires before you sign.
  5. Price the payroll engine separately. For employer taxes, use our payroll cost calculator. If you also place temps in facilities, see payroll software for staffing agencies, and for general options, payroll services for small business.

FAQ

Is EVV required for private-pay home care clients?
The federal EVV requirement in the 21st Century Cures Act applies to Medicaid-funded personal care services (from 1 January 2020) and home health care services (from 1 January 2023). It doesn't cover private-pay visits, though an agency can use the same clock-in app for every client so payroll runs from one set of hours.
How much does home care payroll software cost?
None of the agency platforms we read on 17 October 2026 publish prices. AxisCare quotes by client count, CareSmartz360 by active clients per month, and AlayaCare adds one-time implementation fees. Household payroll for families is published: Poppins Payroll is $49 a month for one caregiver.
Do agencies still have to pay home care workers overtime?
The regulation at 29 CFR 552.109 still bars third-party employers from the companionship and live-in exemptions. In July 2025 the DOL proposed rescinding it and paused enforcement through Field Assistance Bulletin 2025-4, which says it doesn't change any regulatory requirement. No final rule had been published by 17 October 2026, and state wage laws apply separately.
Can a family use agency payroll software for a private caregiver?
It's the wrong tool. A family that hires a caregiver directly is a household employer and reports Social Security, Medicare and federal unemployment tax on Schedule H with its own Form 1040. In 2026 that applies once you pay one caregiver $3,000 or more in cash wages. Household payroll services file it for you.