MarTech Verdict

Reviews · HR & payroll

Best Church Payroll Services in 2026: 6 Options for Clergy Pay

Six church payroll services compared on published price, clergy FICA settings, housing allowance W-2 reporting and filing help, checked 17 October 2026.

By the MarTech Verdict Editorial Team · Published October 17, 2026

Quick picks

1

Gusto

Best for churches that want a self-serve system with a dedicated minister housing allowance earning type

Simple $49/mo + $6/person · Plus $80/mo + $12/person (monthly)
checked 17 Oct 2026
2

Clergy Financial Resources

Best for churches that want a church-only payroll service with clergy tax specialists on call

From $73/mo (1–2 employees, monthly payroll) · larger churches quote
checked 17 Oct 2026
3

Patriot Software

Best for small churches that want the lowest published full-service price

Full Service $37/mo + $5/worker · Basic $17/mo + $4/worker (monthly)
checked 17 Oct 2026
4

ChurchPayroll by Clergytech

Best for churches that need help with handwritten checks and payroll clean-up

From $16.50 per payroll
checked 17 Oct 2026
5

OnPay

Best for churches with lay staff in more than one state

$49/mo + $6/worker (monthly), multi-state included
checked 17 Oct 2026
6

ACS Technologies Realm Payroll

Best for churches already using Realm church management and accounting

Pricing not published (quote)
checked 17 Oct 2026
How we put this together: We read each provider's official pricing, church and help pages on 17 October 2026 and compared published prices, whether each documents marking a minister exempt from Social Security and Medicare, how it reports the housing allowance on the W-2, whether it offers clergy tax help or withholding options, and whether it files payroll taxes for you. Clergy tax rules come from IRS Publications 15-A (2026), 517 (2025) and 1828. We haven't bought or run these services for this article. Prices are in USD as shown on that date.

People searching for church payroll usually already have a payroll problem: a new pastor, a treasurer who’s retiring, or a W-2 that came out wrong. The underlying reason is that a church runs two tax systems at once. Its lay staff are ordinary employees. Its ordained, licensed or commissioned ministers are employees for income tax while their Social Security and Medicare are paid as self-employment tax, according to IRS Publication 517.

That one rule drives everything a church payroll service has to do. It must skip FICA withholding for ministers, keep the housing allowance out of W-2 wages, showing it in box 14 or a separate note instead (see Publication 15-A), and still withhold normally for the church administrator and custodian. Some churches add a further twist by filing Form 8274, which stops FICA on lay staff wages; those workers then pay self-employment tax themselves once their church pay reaches a small annual threshold set in Publication 15-A.

Two kinds of provider handle this. Mainstream payroll software, such as Gusto, Patriot and OnPay, has added clergy settings at published prices. Church specialists sell payroll as a service with clergy tax expertise attached. The list mixes both and says which is which.

The services

1. Gusto: the most complete self-serve clergy setup

Gusto’s Simple plan is $49 a month + $6 per person, monthly with no contract. Set up as a church in Gusto and you get a dedicated earning type for the pastor’s housing allowance; Gusto’s help article says it calculates neither income tax nor SECA on it, keeps it out of box 1 and adds it up in box 14 at year end. There’s a place to log a minister’s FICA exemption too, and the article lists the states that tax the allowance anyway, including Pennsylvania income tax and Oregon unemployment. Gusto syncs with Aplos church accounting.

Who it isn’t for: churches that want someone to answer clergy tax questions. Gusto’s article points you to a tax advisor.

2. Clergy Financial Resources: church-only service with tax specialists

Clergy Financial Resources, based in Maple Grove, Minnesota, prices church payroll starting at $73 a month, a rate it applies to churches with one or two staff paid monthly, and guarantees the price for 12 months. Year-end W-2s, quarterly returns and direct deposit carry no extra fee, and it offers to set up withholding for the pastor so they don’t have to make quarterly estimated payments, the voluntary arrangement Publication 15-A allows. It also prepares clergy tax returns and includes an HR platform.

Who it isn’t for: churches that want to see a price for five or more staff before calling. Above two employees it’s a quote.

3. Patriot Software: lowest published full-service price

Patriot’s Full Service plan is $37 a month + $5 per worker and files and deposits payroll taxes; Basic is $17 + $4 if the treasurer files. Its church payroll page tells you to create the allowance as a non-taxable pay item labeled for clergy housing, which Patriot then reports in box 14; making it a repeating item means you enter it once. For a pastor and three staff, Full Service comes to $57 a month.

Who it isn’t for: churches that need the minister FICA exemption explained step by step. The church page doesn’t cover it, so ask support.

4. ChurchPayroll by Clergytech: help when the books are messy

Clergytech, in Chesapeake, Ohio, sells ChurchPayroll from $16.50 per payroll. Clergytech says it built the system around ministers’ split tax status and housing allowances. Besides running payroll for you, it will file after the fact for churches that hand-write paychecks, and it sells payroll reviews, fixes and IRS representation.

Who it isn’t for: churches that want employees to have self-service pay stubs by default. Self-service costs extra, and Clergytech doesn’t say how many employees the $16.50 starting price covers.

5. OnPay: flat price with multi-state included

OnPay has one plan: $49 a month plus $6 for each person paid, in as many states as you need. On its church page, OnPay says lay staff taxes are calculated automatically and clergy can be flagged as FICA-exempt, and it offers an accuracy guarantee on its calculations.

Who it isn’t for: churches paying a housing allowance that want written setup steps. OnPay’s church page says nothing about housing allowance setup, its help articles didn’t cover it either (Couldn’t confirm), and OnPay’s FAQ says its team won’t assist with Form 8274.

6. ACS Technologies Realm Payroll: inside your church software

Realm Payroll is part of ACS Technologies’ Realm church management system. ACS says it handles ministerial allowances such as housing and car allowances as payroll adjustments, works out withholding, pays by direct deposit, e-files and prints W-2s, then writes each run into the Realm ledger.

Who it isn’t for: churches not on Realm. Pricing isn’t published; ACS prices Realm plans by typical weekly attendance.

Not every church platform runs payroll. ChurchTrac’s accounting FAQ admits you’ll still need a payroll product for the math and deposits, and Pushpay’s ChurchStaq connects to Gusto rather than paying staff itself.

Quick comparison

ServicePublished price (17 Oct 2026)Mark minister FICA-exemptHousing allowance on W-2Clergy tax help
Gusto$49 + $6/personYes, documentedBox 14, documentedSoftware support only
Clergy Financial ResourcesFrom $73/mo (1–2 staff)Couldn’t confirm in writingCouldn’t confirmYes, clergy tax specialists
Patriot Software$37 + $5/workerNot stated on church pageBox 14, documentedSoftware support only
ChurchPayroll by ClergytechFrom $16.50/payrollCouldn’t confirmSays it handles housing allowanceYes, audits and IRS representation
OnPay$49 + $6/workerYes, documentedCouldn’t confirmSoftware support only
ACS Realm PayrollQuoteCouldn’t confirmHousing allowance adjustments listedCouldn’t confirm

How to choose

  1. List who is a minister and who isn’t. Only ordained, licensed or commissioned ministers get clergy treatment. Everyone else is regular payroll, so a provider that handles lay staff well matters as much.
  2. Ask to see the housing allowance on a sample W-2. Box 1 should exclude it; box 14 (or an attached statement) should show it.
  3. Decide who answers the pastor’s tax questions. If nobody at the church can, a specialist like Clergy Financial Resources or Clergytech is worth the higher price per head.
  4. Check your Form 8274 status. If the church has elected out of FICA for lay staff, confirm the provider can set that up.
  5. Estimate lay staff costs with the payroll cost calculator, leaving out FUTA (churches don’t owe it) and the pastor’s FICA.

For other tax-exempt employers, see the best nonprofit payroll software. If you only need standard payroll, start with the best payroll software for small business.

FAQ

Do churches withhold Social Security and Medicare from a pastor?
No. Under IRS Publication 15-A (2026), nothing is withheld from a minister's ministry pay by default: no income tax, no Social Security, no Medicare. The pastor settles self-employment tax, housing allowance included, on their personal return. If both sides agree, the church can withhold extra income tax each payday to cover that bill, and it shows as federal income tax withheld on the W-2.
How should a church report a housing allowance?
The church officially designates a definite amount before paying it (IRS Publication 517). Publication 15-A keeps a qualifying allowance out of W-2 wages (box 1); the church can show it in box 14 or give the minister a statement instead. Gusto's and Patriot's church documentation both point to box 14.
Do churches pay unemployment tax?
There's no federal unemployment (FUTA) bill for a church, per IRS Publication 1828, its tax guide for religious organizations. Whether state unemployment applies is a state-law question; your state workforce agency can confirm.
How much do church payroll services cost?
Published starting prices on 17 October 2026 ran from $16.50 per payroll at Clergytech's ChurchPayroll and $37 a month + $5 per worker for Patriot Full Service up to $73 a month at Clergy Financial Resources, whose entry rate covers a church with one or two staff. Gusto Simple and OnPay were both $49 a month + $6 per person.