MarTech Verdict

Reviews · HR & payroll

Payroll Services for Small Business 2026: 4 Models, 8 Providers

DIY payroll, full-service software, quoted payroll services and PEOs compared on how they charge and what they handle, with prices checked 24 October 2026.

By the MarTech Verdict Editorial Team · Published October 24, 2026

Quick picks

1

Gusto

Best for most small businesses that want payroll taxes handled without a sales call

Simple $49/mo + $6/person · Plus $80/mo + $12/person (monthly)
checked 24 Oct 2026
2

RUN Powered by ADP

Best for owners who want a packaged service with garnishment and unemployment insurance services included

Pricing not published (quote)
checked 24 Oct 2026
3

Justworks PEO

Best for small teams that want payroll, benefits and HR compliance through co-employment at a published rate

Basic $79/employee/mo · Plus $124/employee/mo · no base fee
checked 24 Oct 2026
4

OnPay

Best for a flat, all-inclusive full-service plan with multi-state included

$49/mo + $6/employee (monthly)
checked 24 Oct 2026
5

Paycor

Best for businesses that want payroll and HR from one quoted provider

Pricing not published (quote for under 50 employees)
checked 11 Oct 2026
6

Insperity

Best for companies that want a high-touch PEO with a fixed per-employee service fee

Quote · fixed per-employee fee plus direct costs
checked 24 Oct 2026
7

Patriot Software Basic

Best for owners comfortable filing payroll taxes themselves to keep costs minimal

$17/mo + $4/worker · Full Service $37/mo + $5/worker
checked 24 Oct 2026
8

Paychex Flex

Best for businesses that want a large national provider with service reps

Couldn't confirm
checked 11 Oct 2026
How we put this together: We read each provider's official pricing and product pages on 11 October 2026 and re-checked the published prices on 24 October 2026 (Paycor's page wasn't re-read). We sorted providers by service model (do-it-yourself software, full-service software, quoted payroll services and PEOs), compared how each charges and what each handles, and worked out the monthly cost at 10 employees from published list prices. We couldn't confirm Paychex's pricing. We haven't bought any of these services for this article. Prices are in USD as shown on that date.

“Payroll service” covers four quite different things. Some products only calculate pay and leave the tax filing to you. Some file every tax form automatically for a published monthly fee. Some are sold as packages through a sales rep. And some, PEOs, take on part of the employer role itself. The price gap between the cheapest and the most complete option is roughly ten times.

So before comparing providers, decide which model you’re buying. This guide explains the four, shows what each costs for a 10-person team, and then lists eight providers that represent them. If you already know you want software, our ranked list of the best payroll software for small business goes deeper on that model.

The four ways to outsource payroll

ModelWhat it handlesHow it chargesExample at 10 employees
Do-it-yourself softwarePay calculations, direct deposit, pay stubs. You file and pay taxes.Base + per workerPatriot Basic: $57/mo
Full-service softwareAll of the above, plus federal, state and local tax payments and filings, W-2s and 1099sBase + per personGusto Simple or OnPay: $109/mo
Quoted payroll serviceFull service, sold in packages with optional HR, hiring and compliance extrasQuoteADP, Paycor, Paychex: not published
PEO (co-employment)Payroll, taxes, benefits access, workers’ comp and HR compliance, shared with the PEOPer employee, or a fee plus direct costsJustworks PEO Basic: $790/mo

Two details change the math. First, most “per person” fees count everyone paid in the month, contractors included. Second, PEO fees aren’t the whole cost: benefits premiums, workers’ comp and payroll taxes are usually billed alongside. TriNet, for example, describes its pricing as a per-employee-per-month service fee plus separate costs for benefits, workers’ comp, payroll taxes and add-ons.

Local payroll bureaus and accounting firms are a fifth option. They show up in local search results for this topic, and they usually quote per pay run or per month. Ask the same questions you’d ask any provider here.

The providers

1. Gusto: full-service software for most small businesses

Gusto’s Simple plan is $49 a month plus $6 per person, with unlimited payroll runs and automatic tax filings and payments. Plus ($80 plus $12 per person) adds next-day pay, time tracking, multi-state payroll and contractor invoicing. Premium ($180 plus $22) adds HR guidance and compliance help. There’s no contract. Gusto also connects to health insurance brokers and offers fractional HR support for eligible Plus and Premium customers.

Limit: Gusto isn’t a PEO, so it doesn’t give you access to pooled benefits plans.

2. RUN Powered by ADP: a packaged service

RUN is ADP’s payroll for 1 to 49 employees. The four packages add services step by step: Enhanced adds a state unemployment insurance service, a garnishment payment service and ZipRecruiter; Complete Payroll & HR Plus adds basic HR support; HR Pro adds more HR support and perks. When we checked on 24 October 2026, ADP advertised up to six months free for new clients who sign and start processing by 26 November 2026, with the free months applied to months 4 to 6 and 13 to 15.

Limit: prices aren’t published, so you can’t compare packages without a sales conversation.

3. Justworks PEO: a PEO with a public rate card

Justworks is unusual among PEOs because it publishes prices: Basic is $79 per employee per month and Plus is $124, with no base fee. Plus adds medical, dental and vision administration, HSA and FSA, and mental health and fertility benefits. Dedicated HR consulting is a $30 per employee add-on. Justworks also sells payroll on its own ($50 plus $8 per employee) for teams not ready for a PEO.

Limit: at 10 employees, Basic costs about seven times as much as full-service software. It pays off only if you’ll use the benefits and HR support.

4. OnPay: a single all-in plan

OnPay’s payroll plan is $49 a month plus $6 per employee and includes unlimited pay runs, every federal, state and local filing, year-end forms and payroll in any number of states. It says there are no implementation fees. HR and time tracking are optional add-ons.

Limit: HR tools are basic compared with Gusto Premium or a PEO.

5. Paycor: built to grow past 50

Paycor quotes prices for businesses under 50 employees rather than publishing them, and it sells HR and payroll as one platform. Its pricing page advertised 50% off for the first 6 months, with no end date shown.

Limit: quote-only pricing, so you can’t check the cost of each module before talking to sales.

6. Insperity: a high-touch PEO

Insperity’s HR360 PEO charges a fixed-dollar fee per employee plus “direct cost allocations” for payroll taxes, workers’ comp, benefits and liability coverage. Insperity says the per-employee fee doesn’t rise when you give raises. New HR360 clients could get a credit of up to $425 per full-time employee, ending 31 December 2026, subject to eligibility. Non-PEO options exist too (HRCore).

Limit: you’ll need a quote and a sales process to see the real number.

7. Patriot Software Basic: do-it-yourself and cheap

Patriot Basic is $17 a month plus $4 per worker. It runs the calculations, direct deposit and pay stubs, and you file and pay the taxes. If that’s more than you want to handle, Patriot’s Full Service plan ($37 plus $5, and $12 a month for each extra state) files them for you.

Limit: tax mistakes on Basic are yours to fix. It suits owners with a bookkeeper or a single-state, stable payroll.

8. Paychex Flex: national provider, pricing unconfirmed

Paychex is a long-established national payroll provider. We couldn’t confirm its plans or prices. Treat it like ADP: ask for a written quote that lists every per-run, per-employee and year-end charge.

Limit: without published prices, compare quotes carefully against the software options above.

Quick comparison

ProviderModelPrice (24 Oct 2026)Taxes filed for youBenefits through the provider
GustoFull-service software$49 + $6/personYesBroker integration
RUN by ADPQuoted serviceNot publishedYesCouldn’t confirm
Justworks PEOPEO$79–$124/employeeYesYes, through co-employment
OnPayFull-service software$49 + $6/employeeYesCouldn’t confirm
PaycorQuoted serviceNot publishedYesCouldn’t confirm
InsperityPEOQuoteYesYes, through co-employment
Patriot BasicDo-it-yourself software$17 + $4/workerNo (Full Service: yes)No
Paychex FlexQuoted serviceCouldn’t confirmCouldn’t confirmCouldn’t confirm

How to choose

  1. Pick the model before the provider. If you don’t need benefits through the provider, a PEO is the wrong price bracket.
  2. Ask every quoted provider for a written breakdown. Base fee, per-employee fee, per-run fees, year-end forms, state add-ons and what changes after any promotional period.
  3. Count contractors. Most per-person fees include them, which matters for agencies and trades that use many 1099 workers.
  4. Check who owns tax mistakes. Full-service providers file for you; find out what they cover if a filing is late or wrong.
  5. Plan the next step. Some providers (Justworks, ADP, Insperity) offer both payroll and a PEO, which makes moving up easier later.

FAQ

How much does a payroll service cost for a small business?
It depends on the model. From published prices read on 24 October 2026, for 10 employees: do-it-yourself software ran about $57 a month (Patriot Basic), full-service software about $87 to $130 a month (Patriot Full Service to Justworks Payroll, with Gusto Simple and OnPay at $109), and a PEO with a published rate about $790 a month (Justworks PEO Basic at $79 per employee). ADP, Paycor, Paychex, Insperity and TriNet quote prices instead of publishing them.
What's the difference between a payroll service and a PEO?
A payroll service runs payroll and files taxes for your company. A PEO goes further through co-employment: it shares employer responsibilities with you and reports wages and pays payroll taxes under its own tax ID, which is how it can offer pooled benefits, workers' comp and HR support. PEOs cost more per employee.
Is there free payroll for small businesses?
None of the providers we read offered free full-service payroll. Several advertised free months or discounts for new customers, such as ADP's offer of up to six months free for new clients who sign and start by 26 November 2026. Square charges no base fee if you pay only contractors ($6 per person).
Should I use a local payroll company or an online service?
A local bureau or CPA firm can suit businesses that want a named person handling payroll and are happy to pay a quoted fee. Online full-service software publishes its prices and files taxes automatically. Ask a local provider for its per-run or monthly fee and what happens if a filing is late, then compare it with the published prices here.