MarTech Verdict

Reviews · HR & payroll

Best Payroll Software for Small Business 2026: 10 Picks, Real Costs

Ten small-business payroll tools ranked, with base fees, per-person fees and the monthly bill at 5 and 15 employees, checked 24 October 2026.

By the MarTech Verdict Editorial Team · Published October 22, 2026

Quick picks

1

OnPay

Best for one all-inclusive plan with multi-state payroll and year-end forms included

$49/mo + $6/employee (monthly)
checked 24 Oct 2026
2

Gusto

Best for growing teams that want payroll, benefits and HR tools on one account

Simple $49/mo + $6/person · Plus $80/mo + $12/person (monthly)
checked 24 Oct 2026
3

Patriot Software

Best for the lowest bill for full-service payroll with tax filing

Full Service $37/mo + $5/worker · Basic $17/mo + $4/worker (monthly)
checked 24 Oct 2026
4

QuickBooks Payroll

Best for businesses whose books already live in QuickBooks

From $50/mo + $7/employee (monthly, list price)
checked 24 Oct 2026
5

Square Payroll

Best for shops and restaurants already taking payments with Square

$35/mo + $6/person paid · contractor-only $6/person
checked 24 Oct 2026
6

Wave Payroll

Best for very small businesses that use Wave for invoicing and accounting

$40/mo + $6/active employee or contractor
checked 24 Oct 2026
7

SurePayroll

Best for a low base fee for a handful of employees in one state

From $29/mo + $7/employee · year-end forms extra
checked 24 Oct 2026
8

Justworks Payroll

Best for teams that may move up to a PEO later without switching vendors

$50/mo + $8/employee (monthly)
checked 24 Oct 2026
9

Homebase

Best for hourly, shift-based teams that need scheduling and time clocks

Payroll add-on $49/mo + $6/employee after a 6-month free period
checked 24 Oct 2026
10

RUN Powered by ADP

Best for owners who want a large provider and phone-based setup

Pricing not published (quote)
checked 24 Oct 2026
How we put this together: We read each vendor's official pricing page on 11 October 2026 and re-checked every price on 24 October 2026. We compared base fees, per-person fees, which plan files taxes for you, multi-state support and add-on costs, then worked out the monthly bill at 5 and 15 employees from those list prices. We haven't run payroll on these tools for this article. Prices are in USD as shown on that date, before promotions.

Small-business payroll software has settled on one pricing model: a monthly base fee plus a charge for every person you pay. That makes the headline price misleading. A $35 base with a $6 per-person fee is cheaper than a $49 base at 5 employees, but the gap shrinks as you hire, and add-ons like next-day deposit or time tracking can change the order.

So this list ranks tools on fit and total cost, not the smallest number on the page. For each one we give the entry price, what it includes, and the case where you should pick something else. The cost table further down shows the monthly bill at 5 and 15 employees.

A few terms first:

  • Full-service payroll means the software calculates, pays and files your payroll taxes (federal, state and local) and produces W-2s and 1099s.
  • Per person usually counts everyone paid in the month, contractors included. Check each vendor’s definition.
  • Multi-state matters the moment you hire someone remote. Some tools charge extra for it.

The tools

1. OnPay: one plan, few surprises

OnPay sells a single payroll plan at $49 a month plus $6 per employee. That plan includes unlimited pay runs, federal, state and local tax filings, W-2s, 1099s and year-end filings, and payroll in as many states as you need. OnPay says there are no implementation fees, and support is by phone, chat and email. HR tools ($15 base plus $2 per worker) and time tracking ($15 plus $4) are optional add-ons.

Who it isn’t for: businesses that want a big HR suite with performance reviews and benefits strategy on top of payroll. OnPay keeps HR as a light add-on.

2. Gusto: the widest path as you grow

Gusto Simple is $49 a month plus $6 per person and covers unlimited payroll runs, tax filings and payments, and basic time off. Plus ($80 plus $12 per person) adds time tracking and scheduling, next-day pay, multi-state payroll and workforce cost reports. Premium ($180 plus $22) adds same-day and instant pay, HR guidance and Gusto’s compliance service. There’s no contract and setup is free, according to the pricing page. A $49 Solo plan covers an owner paying only themselves.

Who it isn’t for: cost-focused teams on Simple who need next-day pay or multi-state. Those cost extra on Simple, so price Plus as your real plan if you have remote hires.

3. Patriot Software: the cheapest full-service plan

Patriot’s Full Service plan is $37 a month plus $5 per worker paid, and it files federal, state and local taxes and year-end forms at no extra fee. Each additional state adds $12 a month. Basic Payroll ($17 plus $4) does the calculations and direct deposit but leaves the tax filing to you. Time and attendance and HR add-ons are $6 a month plus $2 per employee each. Patriot advertised a free trial and a discount for new customers, with no end date shown.

Who it isn’t for: teams that want benefits administration or modern HR features in the same tool. Patriot is payroll-first and plain by design.

4. QuickBooks Payroll: if QuickBooks runs your books

QuickBooks’ payroll-only plans start at $50 a month plus $7 per employee (Payroll), then $88 plus $13 (Premium) and $134 plus $17 (Elite), at list price. The entry plan includes full-service filing, next-day direct deposit, auto payroll and 1099 e-filing. Premium adds same-day deposit, time tracking and HR workflows. Elite adds tax penalty protection up to $25,000 a year and a personal HR advisor. Bundles with QuickBooks accounting are also sold. QuickBooks advertised 50% off the base fee for 3 months, with no end date shown.

Who it isn’t for: businesses that don’t use QuickBooks accounting. Outside that setup, its prices aren’t the lowest here.

5. Square Payroll: for Square sellers

Square Payroll costs $35 a month plus $6 per person paid for full-service payroll, with no contract. If you only pay contractors, it’s $6 per person with no base fee. Paper W-2 and 1099 mailing costs $3 per form per year. The natural fit is a café, shop or salon already using Square for payments and staff timecards.

Who it isn’t for: office-based teams with no Square hardware or point of sale. The connection to Square’s other products is the main reason to choose it.

6. Wave Payroll: for Wave accounting users

Wave charges $40 a month plus $6 per active employee and $6 per contractor paid in the US, with a 30-day free trial. Tax payments and filings are automated, though Wave’s page notes this excludes 1099 filings. It pairs with Wave’s free invoicing and accounting.

Who it isn’t for: teams with contractors who want 1099 filing handled for them, or anyone outside Wave’s ecosystem.

7. SurePayroll: low base, extra year-end fees

SurePayroll’s small-business plan starts at $29 a month plus $7 per employee, with unlimited payroll runs and automatic tax filing and deposits. Each additional state is $9.99 a month. Year-end W-2 and 1099 filing is billed separately at a $50 base fee plus $5 per form. A separate household payroll plan is $39 a month with one employee included.

Who it isn’t for: multi-state teams. The state fee and year-end charges add up compared with OnPay or Gusto Plus.

8. Justworks Payroll: a step toward a PEO

Justworks Payroll is $50 a month plus $8 per employee, and US contractors are $8 each per month. Its main appeal is the upgrade path: Justworks also runs a PEO with published per-employee rates, so a business can add benefits through co-employment later without changing vendors.

Who it isn’t for: teams that will stay on payroll only. The per-employee fee is the highest of the base-plus-person plans here.

9. Homebase: scheduling first, payroll second

Homebase is a scheduling and time clock app for hourly teams. Scheduling plans run from free to $120 per location per month. Payroll is an add-on at $49 a month plus $6 per employee, and the page says the first 6 months of payroll are free (no end date shown). Hours from the time clock flow straight into payroll.

Who it isn’t for: salaried teams. Without shifts and time clocks, you’re paying for scheduling you won’t use.

10. RUN Powered by ADP: big provider, quoted price

RUN is ADP’s payroll for businesses with 1 to 49 employees. It comes in four packages: Essential, Enhanced (which adds state unemployment insurance service and garnishment payments), Complete Payroll & HR Plus and HR Pro. ADP doesn’t publish prices; you request a quote. On 24 October 2026 it advertised up to six months free for new clients who sign and start processing by 26 November 2026, replacing a three-month offer that ended 22 October. Its terms apply the free months to months 4 to 6 and 13 to 15.

Who it isn’t for: owners who want to compare prices without a sales call.

Quick comparison

Monthly bill at list price, before promotions and add-ons.

ToolBase + per person5 employees15 employeesMulti-state
OnPay$49 + $6$79$139Included
Gusto Simple$49 + $6$79$139On Plus ($80 + $12)
Patriot Full Service$37 + $5$62$112$12/mo per extra state
QuickBooks Payroll$50 + $7$85$155Couldn’t confirm
Square Payroll$35 + $6$65$125Couldn’t confirm
Wave Payroll$40 + $6$70$130Couldn’t confirm
SurePayroll$29 + $7$64$134$9.99/mo per extra state
Justworks Payroll$50 + $8$90$170Couldn’t confirm
Homebase payroll$49 + $6$79$139Couldn’t confirm
RUN by ADPNot publishedQuoteQuoteQuote

SurePayroll’s year-end fees ($50 plus $5 per form) come on top, billed annually.

How to choose

  1. Price your headcount in a year, not today. A low base with a higher per-person fee loses its edge as you hire.
  2. List the add-ons you’ll need on day one. Next-day deposit, time tracking and multi-state support are included on some entry plans and extra on others.
  3. Decide whether you’ll file taxes yourself. If not, compare only full-service plans. Patriot Basic is cheap because you do the filing.
  4. Match the tool to where your data already lives. QuickBooks for QuickBooks books, Square for Square sellers, Homebase for shift schedules.
  5. Read promotion terms before you sign. Several vendors advertise free months or discounts. Note when they end and what the price becomes.

FAQ

What is the cheapest payroll software that still files taxes for you?
Of the published prices we read on 24 October 2026, Patriot Software's Full Service plan was the lowest at $37 a month plus $5 per worker paid, with federal, state and local filings and year-end forms included. For 5 employees that's $62 a month at list price. Patriot's Basic plan is cheaper ($17 plus $4 per worker) but you file the taxes yourself.
Is Gusto or QuickBooks better for small business payroll?
On list price they're close: Gusto Simple was $49 a month plus $6 per person, and QuickBooks Payroll was $50 plus $7 per employee. QuickBooks makes more sense if your books are already in QuickBooks, and its entry plan includes next-day direct deposit. Gusto's entry plan charges $15 a month plus $3 per person for next-day pay, but Gusto has more HR and benefits options as you grow.
How much does payroll software cost for 10 employees?
Using list prices read on 24 October 2026: Patriot Full Service $87 a month, Square $95, Wave $100, OnPay and Gusto Simple $109 each, QuickBooks Payroll $120 and Justworks Payroll $130. ADP doesn't publish prices for RUN.
Does ADP publish its small-business payroll prices?
No. ADP's RUN page lists four packages (Essential, Enhanced, Complete Payroll & HR Plus and HR Pro) but asks you to request pricing. On 24 October 2026 it advertised up to six months free for new clients who sign and start processing by 26 November 2026, replacing a three-month offer that ended 22 October.