Best Payroll Services for Restaurants in 2026: 7 Ranked
Seven restaurant payroll services ranked on tip pooling, tip makeup, POS tip import and FICA tip credit support, with prices checked 17 October 2026.
Quick picks
Toast Payroll
Best for restaurants on Toast POS that want tip pools and tip makeup calculated for them
checked 17 Oct 2026
OnPay
Best for restaurants that want payroll independent of their POS, with tip makeup and Form 8846 handled
checked 17 Oct 2026
Square Payroll
Best for cafes and counter-service spots already taking payments on Square
checked 17 Oct 2026
Gusto
Best for owners who want payroll, benefits and HR in one account
checked 17 Oct 2026
7shifts Payroll
Best for restaurants that already build schedules and split tips in 7shifts
checked 17 Oct 2026
Homebase
Best for small hourly teams that want scheduling and a POS-fed tip pool
checked 17 Oct 2026
RUN Powered by ADP
Best for multi-unit groups that want phone-led service and pay cards
checked 17 Oct 2026
If you’re searching for restaurant payroll, the hard part probably isn’t paychecks. It’s the tip math around them: someone is reconciling POS tip reports against the time clock, splitting a pool and checking that nobody on a $2.13 cash wage fell below minimum wage that week.
Those checks come straight from federal rules. DOL Fact Sheet #15 lets you count up to $5.12 of tips toward the $7.25 minimum, but bars managers and supervisors from any share of the pool. It also limits back-of-house staff to pools where no tip credit is taken. And from tax year 2026, the W-2 instructions want cash tips in box 12 with code TP and a tipped occupation code in box 14b.
There’s money on the table too. Restaurants pay 7.65% employer FICA on reported tips and can claim most of it back on Form 8846. The 2025 instructions exclude only the tips needed to bring each server’s cash wage up to $5.15 an hour. For example (our arithmetic), $3,000 of creditable tips in a month is worth $229.50 in credit. That only works if payroll keeps monthly tip and wage figures per employee.
So this list ranks providers by how much of that tip work they say they do for you, not by headline price.
The tools
1. Toast Payroll: the most tip work done for you
Toast lists a POS and Payroll bundle from $90 a month plus $9 per employee, which covers Toast POS software, payroll essentials and basic scheduling. Toast says payroll pulls hours and tips from the POS, pools tips across front and back of house by rules you set and calculates “tip makeup to minimum”. It also handles overtime across locations and staff with several pay rates. Its MyToast app gives staff pay and tip visibility.
Limitation: it’s built around Toast POS. There’s no published payroll-only price for existing Toast customers, and we couldn’t confirm Form 8846 or Form 8027 reporting.
2. OnPay: restaurant features without POS lock-in
OnPay charges $49 a month plus $6 per worker on one plan, with multi-state payroll included. Its restaurant page says it adds tip makeup automatically when wages plus tips fall below the minimum. It also records tips as a separate pay item, supports multiple pay rates and lists Form 8846 among the filings it automates. Pay-as-you-go workers’ comp is available.
Limitation: OnPay doesn’t name Toast, Square or Clover integrations or mention tip pooling, so pool splits happen before tips reach payroll.
3. Square Payroll: cheapest if you’re on Square
Square’s full-service payroll is $35 a month plus $6 per person paid, with multi-state payroll included. Square says it imports direct tips and timecards from Square POS, calculates overtime and handles multiple pay rates. A contractor-only plan is $6 per person with no base fee.
Limitation: we couldn’t confirm tip pooling, tip makeup or Form 8846 support on Square’s payroll pages.
4. Gusto: payroll plus benefits
Gusto Simple is $49 a month plus $6 per person (one state); Plus is $80 plus $12 and adds time tracking and multi-state payroll. Gusto’s help center separates cash tips, card tips and distributed service charges. It also covers FLSA tip credit setup and claiming the Form 8846 credit. Gusto says it works with 7shifts and Upserve.
Limitation: its tip-tracking time clock is a Plus feature, which doubles the per-person fee compared with Simple.
5. 7shifts Payroll: if 7shifts already runs your schedule
7shifts Payroll costs $39.99 a month per location plus $6 per employee paid, added to any paid 7shifts plan. It’s US-only with no contract. 7shifts says payroll pulls in hours and tip payouts. Its tip management tool, an add-on or part of the top plan, calculates and distributes tips and sends them to payroll.
Limitation: you pay for a scheduling plan on top, and we couldn’t confirm 7shifts’ US plan prices.
6. Homebase: scheduling first, payroll second
Homebase payroll is $49 a month plus $6 per employee paid, on top of any Homebase plan (Essentials is $30 per location monthly). Its Tip Manager add-on costs $25 per location a month. Homebase says it pulls tips from your POS, calculates the pool and adds it to timesheets.
Limitation: Homebase’s pricing page doesn’t explain how payroll handles tip credits or tip makeup.
7. RUN Powered by ADP: for groups that want a rep
ADP doesn’t publish RUN prices. Its restaurant page says it connects to your POS to capture time and tips and tracks multiple jobs and pay rates. It names a Clover POS integration and offers Wisely pay cards for staff without bank accounts.
Limitation: quote-only pricing, and the restaurant page doesn’t describe tip pooling, tip makeup or Form 8846.
Quick comparison
| Provider | Price (17 Oct 2026) | Tips imported from POS | Tip pooling | Tip makeup to minimum | Form 8846 documented |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Toast Payroll | $90/mo + $9/employee (with POS) | Yes, Toast POS | Yes | Yes | Couldn’t confirm |
| OnPay | $49/mo + $6/worker | Not listed | Not listed | Yes | Yes |
| Square Payroll | $35/mo + $6/person | Yes, Square POS | Couldn’t confirm | Couldn’t confirm | Couldn’t confirm |
| Gusto | $49 + $6 or $80 + $12 | Via 7shifts, Upserve | Couldn’t confirm | Tip credit setup | Yes |
| 7shifts Payroll | $39.99/location + $6, plus plan | Via 7shifts tips | Yes, tip add-on | Couldn’t confirm | Couldn’t confirm |
| Homebase | $49 + $6, plus plan | Yes, Tip Manager | Yes, Tip Manager | Couldn’t confirm | Couldn’t confirm |
| ADP RUN | Quote | Yes, POS connection | Not listed | Not listed | Not listed |
How to choose
- Start from your POS. If you’re on Toast or Square, test their payroll first. Tips that never leave the system can’t be mistyped. If you might switch POS, OnPay or Gusto keeps payroll separate.
- Price your real headcount. Base fee plus per-person fee, plus any scheduling plan or tip add-on you need. Our payroll cost calculator adds employer taxes on top.
- Ask for a slow-week demo. Have each provider show a server whose tips didn’t cover the gap to minimum wage, and someone who worked a tipped and a non-tipped shift at different rates.
- Check the year-end forms. Ask who prepares Form 8027 (required where tipping is customary and you normally had more than 10 employees on a typical day) and how box 12 code TP and box 14b will be filled.
- Compare against general payroll. If tips are a small part of pay, a general tool from our best payroll software for small business list may be cheaper. Our Gusto vs ADP comparison covers the two biggest names.
FAQ
- What do restaurants need from a payroll service that other businesses don't?
- Tip handling. Under DOL Fact Sheet #15 you can pay tipped staff $2.13 an hour in cash and count up to $5.12 of tips toward the $7.25 federal minimum, but you must top up any workweek where tips fall short, keep managers out of the tip pool and pay card tips by the next payday. Your payroll service should import tips, run the pool and calculate the top-up for you.
- How much does restaurant payroll cost per month?
- For a 20-person restaurant on 17 October 2026 published prices, our arithmetic gives $155 a month for Square Payroll, $169 for OnPay or Gusto Simple, $159.99 for 7shifts Payroll before its plan fee, and $270 for Toast's POS and Payroll bundle, which includes the POS software. ADP and Paychex quote.
- Which payroll services handle the FICA tip credit?
- OnPay lists Form 8846 among the filings it automates, and Gusto's help center explains how to claim the credit in Gusto. For restaurants, the 2025 Form 8846 instructions measure the credit against $5.15 an hour, so tips used to bring cash wages up to $5.15 don't count. We couldn't confirm Form 8846 support on the other providers' pages.
- What changes on restaurant W-2s for 2026?
- The 2026 W-2 instructions add box 12 code TP for cash tips reported to you and box 14b for up to two Treasury Tipped Occupation Codes, such as 101 for bartenders and 102 for wait staff. They support the employee deduction for qualified tips that runs from 2025 through 2028.
Related reviews
- Deel Review 2026: Every Published Price, From Contractors to PEO
- Rippling Review 2026: What You Get, What It Costs, Who It Suits
- Best PEO for Small Business in 2026: 7 Co-Employment Options Ranked
- Gusto vs ADP in 2026: Published Prices vs a Sales Quote
- Payroll Services for Small Business 2026: 4 Models, 8 Providers
- Best Payroll Software for Small Business 2026: 10 Picks, Real Costs
- Best Canadian Payroll Services in 2026: 8 Providers Compared
- Best Church Payroll Services in 2026: 6 Options for Clergy Pay