Best Nonprofit Payroll Software in 2026: 6 Options Compared
Six nonprofit payroll options compared on published price, 501(c)(3) tax settings and grant cost allocation, with prices checked 17 October 2026.
Quick picks
Gusto
Best for most small 501(c)(3)s, thanks to written help for FUTA exemption and unemployment reimbursement
checked 17 Oct 2026
OnPay
Best for nonprofits with staff in several states that want one flat plan
checked 17 Oct 2026
Paylocity
Best for larger grant-funded organizations that want labor allocation inside payroll
checked 17 Oct 2026
Patriot Software
Best for very small nonprofits that want the lowest published price
checked 17 Oct 2026
Aplos (payroll through Gusto)
Best for organizations whose main problem is getting payroll into the right fund
checked 17 Oct 2026
RUN Powered by ADP
Best for nonprofits that want a sales-led setup and a state unemployment claims service
checked 17 Oct 2026
Most nonprofit payroll runs on the same engines as small-business payroll. The difference is in two settings and one report. The settings are your federal unemployment status and your state unemployment method. The report is the one that shows which grant paid for whose time.
The tax piece is simple once it’s set. IRS Publication 15-A exempts 501(c)(3) organizations from FUTA, which Publication 15 puts at 6.0% of the first $7,000 per employee before state credits. Social Security and Medicare still apply. The grant piece is harder: for federal awards, 2 CFR 200.430(g) requires salary charges to rest on records that reflect actual work, and to support the split when someone works across several awards or funding sources.
So the ranking below weighs three things beyond price: whether the provider documents a 501(c)(3) setup, whether it handles reimbursing employers for state unemployment, and how it gets payroll costs to the right fund.
Two smaller items are worth raising on any demo call. Retirement plans at a 501(c)(3) are often 403(b)s rather than 401(k)s; the IRS sets the 2026 elective deferral limit at $24,500, and its universal availability rule generally means offering salary deferral to every employee once you offer it to one. And salaried program staff still need to clear the FLSA’s exempt salary level, which the Department of Labor lists as $684 a week, unless your state sets a higher bar.
The tools
1. Gusto: the most documented nonprofit setup
Gusto’s Simple plan is $49 a month + $6 per person and covers one state; Plus is $80 + $12 and adds multi-state payroll and time tracking. Its state unemployment help article walks through marking the company as a FUTA-exempt 501(c)(3) and switching on reimbursing-employer status state by state. Gusto also syncs payroll into Aplos fund accounting. At 12 employees, Simple works out to $121 a month.
Who it isn’t for: organizations with staff in several states on a tight budget, since multi-state needs Plus. Project costing is listed only on Premium ($180 + $22).
2. OnPay: one plan, any number of states
OnPay sells a single payroll plan at $49 a month + $6 per worker, with multi-state payroll, W-2s and 1099s included. Its nonprofit page says it handles FUTA exemptions for 501(c)(3) organizations and can pay employees, contractors, volunteers and board members. Setup and migration of prior wage data are free.
Who it isn’t for: grant-heavy organizations. OnPay’s own answer to splitting pay by grant is to run separate pay runs, not allocate one paycheck across funds.
3. Paylocity: labor allocation built in
Paylocity is the only provider here whose nonprofit page describes splitting pay and spend by funding source and grant, plus reports aimed at Form 990 season. It also bundles HR, time, learning and benefits administration in one system. That’s the right shape for an organization with many grants and a finance team that reports to funders monthly.
Who it isn’t for: small teams that want to see a price first. Paylocity quotes after a demo.
4. Patriot Software: lowest published price
Patriot’s Full Service plan is $37 a month + $5 per worker and files and deposits federal, state and local taxes; Basic is $17 + $4 if you file yourself. Its nonprofit page has a switch to turn off federal and, where your state allows, state unemployment tax for a tax-exempt employer. Health insurance is available through SimplyInsured.
Who it isn’t for: multi-state organizations (Full Service adds $12 a month per extra state) or anyone who needs grant allocation in payroll.
5. Aplos with Gusto: payroll that lands in the right fund
Aplos is nonprofit and church fund accounting, and it doesn’t run payroll itself. Its Gusto partnership page explains the flow: you run payroll in Gusto, and each run posts to Aplos already coded to the funds and programs you assigned staff to once. Aplos Lite is $79 a month, Core $129 and Advanced from $229; budgeting by fund or grant is on Advanced.
Who it isn’t for: organizations happy with their current accounting system. You’d be paying for two products.
6. RUN Powered by ADP: sales-led, with a claims service
ADP’s nonprofit page talks about exemption handling, FLSA compliance tools and syncing payroll with your accounting system. RUN has four packages for teams under 50, and the Enhanced tier bundles a service for state unemployment insurance. Every package is quote-only.
Who it isn’t for: anyone who wants to compare prices online. ADP’s page also doesn’t describe grant allocation.
If you already use Blackbaud’s Financial Edge NXT for fund accounting, its product page points to payroll integrations through the Blackbaud Marketplace rather than its own payroll. Pricing there is quote-only too.
Quick comparison
| Provider | Published price (17 Oct 2026) | 501(c)(3) FUTA setting | Reimbursing-employer SUI | Grant or fund allocation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gusto | $49 + $6/person | Yes, documented | Yes, per state | Via Aplos sync; project costing on Premium |
| OnPay | $49 + $6/worker | Yes | Couldn’t confirm | Separate pay runs |
| Paylocity | Quote | Couldn’t confirm | Couldn’t confirm | Yes, grant tracking and labor allocation |
| Patriot Software | $37 + $5/worker | Yes (FUTA and SUTA) | Couldn’t confirm | Not documented |
| Aplos + Gusto | $79–$229 + Gusto | Through Gusto | Through Gusto | Yes, maps payroll to funds |
| RUN Powered by ADP | Quote | Mentions tax exemptions | SUI service on Enhanced | Not documented |
How to choose
- Count your funding sources. One or two unrestricted funds? Any of the cheaper tools works. Several federal grants charged to the same people? Look at Paylocity, or Gusto with Aplos.
- Decide your state unemployment method first. If you’ll reimburse the state instead of paying tax, confirm the provider can turn off SUI calculations for that state.
- Price your real headcount. Use the payroll cost calculator for employer taxes, then remember a 501(c)(3) owes no FUTA.
- Ask how volunteers and stipends are paid. OnPay and ADP mention paying volunteers; anything tied to hours should run through payroll.
- Check the year-end outputs. You’ll want payroll reports that feed Form 990’s split between program, management and fundraising costs.
Running a church instead? See the best church payroll services, which handle clergy tax rules. For general options, see the best payroll software for small business.
FAQ
- Do nonprofits pay payroll taxes?
- Yes, mostly. IRS Publication 15-A (2026) says a 501(c)(3) is exempt from federal unemployment tax (FUTA), and that exemption can't be waived, yet income tax withholding, Social Security and Medicare all still apply. The only FICA exception for a 501(c)(3) is an employee paid under $100 in the year (or a church that has filed Form 8274). Other exempt organizations, such as 501(c)(6) trade groups, pay FUTA.
- What is the cheapest nonprofit payroll software?
- Among published prices on 17 October 2026, Patriot Software's Basic plan was lowest at $17 a month + $4 per worker, but you file and deposit taxes yourself. Its Full Service plan was $37 a month + $5 per worker, which works out to $87 a month for 10 employees. Gusto Simple and OnPay were both $49 + $6, or $109 for 10.
- Can nonprofit payroll software track grants?
- Paylocity markets labor allocation by funding source, grants included. Aplos maps each employee's Gusto payroll to funds or programs in its accounting. OnPay's FAQ suggests running separate pay runs per grant. If federal awards pay salaries, 2 CFR 200.430(g) also requires records that reflect the work people actually did.
- Should a nonprofit reimburse the state for unemployment instead of paying tax?
- It depends on how stable your staffing is. Reimbursing employers pay the state back for benefits actually paid to former staff; in California, EDD locks nonprofits into that choice for at least five calendar years. Gusto documents a per-state reimbursing-employer setting, so check your provider supports it before you elect.
Related reviews
- Deel Review 2026: Every Published Price, From Contractors to PEO
- Rippling Review 2026: What You Get, What It Costs, Who It Suits
- Best PEO for Small Business in 2026: 7 Co-Employment Options Ranked
- Gusto vs ADP in 2026: Published Prices vs a Sales Quote
- Payroll Services for Small Business 2026: 4 Models, 8 Providers
- Best Payroll Software for Small Business 2026: 10 Picks, Real Costs
- Best Canadian Payroll Services in 2026: 8 Providers Compared
- Best Church Payroll Services in 2026: 6 Options for Clergy Pay