MarTech Verdict

Reviews · Phone & answering

Best Answering Service for Insurance Agents in 2026: 7 Ranked

Seven answering services for insurance agencies compared on AMS integrations, claims-call handling, Spanish and published prices, checked 17 October 2026.

By the MarTech Verdict Editorial Team · Published October 17, 2026

Quick picks

1

Smith.ai

Best for agencies that want live receptionists and an AI option with published prices

Live from $300/mo for 30 calls · AI from $0 (25 calls) or $150/mo (75 calls)
checked 17 Oct 2026
2

Sonant

Best for P&C agencies that want call details written into Applied Epic, AMS360, EZLynx or HawkSoft

Pricing not published (quote)
checked 17 Oct 2026
3

Answering Service Care

Best for the lowest published per-minute rate for live after-hours answering

From $40/mo + $1.75/min · $329/mo for 250 minutes
checked 17 Oct 2026
4

Upfirst

Best for small agencies that want cheap AI answering with transfer rules by topic

From $24.95/mo for 30 calls · $20/mo billed annually
checked 17 Oct 2026
5

Posh

Best for agencies that want live answering with Spanish included and a short trial

From $65/mo + $2.30/min · $215/mo for 100 minutes
checked 17 Oct 2026
6

AnswerConnect

Best for agencies that want an urgent-call plan written at setup

Pricing not published (quote)
checked 17 Oct 2026
7

Rosie

Best for solo agents who want 24/7 AI answering for the least money

From $49/mo for 250 minutes (monthly)
checked 17 Oct 2026
How we put this together: We read each provider's official pricing, insurance-industry and integration pages on 17 October 2026 and compared billing models, agency management system (AMS) integrations, how each describes claims and quote calls, Spanish coverage and after-hours answering. We also read the NAIC Producer Licensing Model Act. We haven't bought or run these services for this article. Prices are in USD as shown on that date.

Agency owners usually start looking for an answering service when the customer service team can’t keep up: renewal questions, certificate requests and “I need to add a car” calls crowd out new business, and after-hours calls go to voicemail. The answer is rarely a generic message-taking service. Insurance calls need two things most industries don’t.

The first is a firm line on licensing. The NAIC’s Producer Licensing Model Act says a person can’t sell, solicit or negotiate insurance without a license, and defines negotiating as advising a buyer on a policy’s benefits, terms or conditions. States pass their own versions, so check your state’s rules. An outside receptionist should collect, route and book, and leave coverage talk to your licensed staff.

The second is somewhere for the information to go. A quote request typed into an email is half the job. The services below differ most on whether call details land in your agency management system, your CRM, or just your inbox.

The services

1. Smith.ai: live and AI, priced in public

Smith.ai bills per call. Live receptionists start at $300 a month for 30 calls, with Basic at $810 for 90 and Pro at $2,100 for 300, and a 30-day money-back guarantee. Five intake questions are included; six extra cost $1.50 per call, and a dedicated Spanish line is $1.00. The AI Receptionist starts with a free 25-call plan and $150 a month for 75 calls. Smith.ai lists independent insurance agents among its industries and integrates with Salesforce and HubSpot.

Limitation: we didn’t find an AMS on its integrations list, so quote details reach you through a CRM, email or Zapier.

2. Sonant: built for agencies, wired into the AMS

Sonant is an AI receptionist made for insurance agencies. It says it takes quote details into your AMS or rater, handles service requests, routes by office, region or product line, answers after hours and on weekends, and hands callers to your team without making them repeat themselves. Its integrations page lists AMS360, Applied Epic, EZLynx, HawkSoft, Momentum AMP and QQCatalyst, plus Calendly and Outlook calendars.

Limitation: it doesn’t publish prices; Sonant says pricing depends on call volume and the number of offices.

3. Answering Service Care: low per-minute live rates

Answering Service Care’s live plans are Starter at $40 a month plus $1.75 a minute, Small Business at $179 for 100 minutes, Pro at $329 for 250 and Enterprise at $639 for 500 ($1.35 per extra minute). Its insurance page is written for agents and adjusters and covers 24/7 live answering, claims-related calls, lead capture and scheduling, with lead details sent to your CRM.

Limitation: no AMS is named, and the pricing page also mentions a start-up fee in its explanatory text.

4. Upfirst: cheap AI with insurance routing

Upfirst charges $24.95 a month for 30 calls ($20 billed annually), $59.95 for 90, $159.95 for 300 and $299 for 600. Its insurance page says agencies use it for first notice of loss, that you can set transfer rules by topic (claims, new business, service), and that it can text a quote-intake form link during the call. It speaks English and Spanish, and connects to AgencyZoom, InsuredMine and NowCerts through Zapier.

Limitation: no direct link to Applied Epic, HawkSoft or EZLynx was named.

5. Posh: live receptionists, Spanish included

Posh bills per minute: $65 a month plus $2.30 a minute, $215 for 100 minutes, $420 for 200, up to $1,900 for 1,000, month to month. English and Spanish receptionists and after-hours answering are included in all plans, and there’s a 7-day or 250-minute free trial. Its insurance page says it answers 24/7 and helps with claims and policy questions, and it names Zapier, Zoho, Salesforce and Acuity integrations.

Limitation: per-minute costs climb fast in a storm week.

6. AnswerConnect: a crisis plan up front

AnswerConnect doesn’t publish prices. Its insurance brokers page says it writes a crisis management plan for urgent calls during setup, and offers 24/7 phone, email and chat answering, call routing, transfers and scheduling.

Limitation: no prices and no named AMS or CRM.

7. Rosie: the lowest-cost AI option

Rosie’s plans are $49 a month for 250 minutes, $149 for 1,000 (adds calendar booking and warm transfers) and $299 for 2,000, with a 7-day free trial. It answers 24/7 in English and Spanish. Its insurance page says it captures quote leads, assists with claims intake and flags urgent claims.

Limitation: the same page says Rosie explains coverage basics and deductibles. For an agency, lock that down so coverage questions go to a licensed person.

Quick comparison

ServiceModelEntry price (17 Oct 2026)AMS integrationSpanish
Smith.aiLive + AI, per call$300/mo live; $0 AINone found$1/call line
SonantAI, insurance-onlyQuoteApplied Epic, AMS360, EZLynx, HawkSoft, QQCatalyst, MomentumMultiple languages
Answering Service CareLive, per minute$40/mo + $1.75/minNone namedYes
UpfirstAI, per call$24.95/moAgencyZoom, InsuredMine, NowCerts via ZapierYes
PoshLive, per minute$65/mo + $2.30/minNone namedYes
AnswerConnectLiveQuoteNone namedCouldn’t confirm
RosieAI, minutes allowance$49/moNone namedYes

A worked example (our arithmetic): an agency that only wants after-hours coverage, at 60 calls a month averaging 4 minutes (240 minutes), would pay $59.95 on Upfirst Premium, $150 on Smith.ai AI Pro, $329 on Answering Service Care Pro, $504 on Posh ($420 for 200 minutes plus 40 at $2.10) or $645 on Smith.ai’s live Starter plan ($300 plus 30 calls at $11.50). Run your own numbers with our missed-call revenue calculator.

How to choose

  1. Decide where calls should land. If you live in Applied Epic, HawkSoft or EZLynx, an AMS-connected service saves re-keying. If you work from a CRM, check that one by name.
  2. Write the licensing line into the script. List what the receptionist may say (hours, documents, carrier claims numbers) and the exact words for handing off coverage questions.
  3. Give it every carrier’s claims number. After-hours claim callers usually need to report to their carrier, so a current list matters more than long notes.
  4. Price a storm month. Double your normal volume and price it on each plan. Per-minute bills double; AI plans with large allowances often don’t.
  5. Test certificate requests. Commercial clients need certificates fast. Make sure the service captures the holder’s name, address and deadline for your account manager.

Also comparing services for other professions? See our virtual receptionists for law firms and answering services for real estate.

FAQ

Can an answering service quote or bind insurance?
Not unless the person on the phone holds the right license in your state. The NAIC model law that most states build on says a person can't sell, solicit or negotiate insurance without a license. None of the services we read said their receptionists are licensed, so use them to collect details and book a licensed producer.
Which answering services connect to an agency management system?
Of the services here, Sonant named the most: Applied Epic, AMS360, EZLynx, HawkSoft, QQCatalyst and Momentum AMP. Upfirst connects to AgencyZoom, InsuredMine and NowCerts through Zapier. The others named general CRMs such as Salesforce, HubSpot or Zoho.
How much does an insurance answering service cost?
On 17 October 2026, live plans started at $40 a month plus $1.75 a minute (Answering Service Care), $65 plus $2.30 a minute (Posh) and $300 for 30 calls (Smith.ai). AI plans started at $24.95 a month (Upfirst) and $49 (Rosie). Sonant and AnswerConnect quote.